Werriwa watch: one week to go

Bryan · Saturday 12 March 2005 · 10:30 am

The Werriwa by-election is next Saturday.

Alan Ramsey in today’s SMH has this wonderfully bitchy piece about the selection of Chris Hayes as the Labor candidate for Werriwa. As Ramsey sees it, there is a risk Labor will lose Werriwa because of the candidate imposed on the electorate by the party machine in the Sussex Street head office.

Personally, I do not think there is too much risk for Labor.

The SMH included this wrap-up on Werriwa.

Citizens of Werriwa be alert but not alarmed - with a week to go before a by-election with 16 revved up candidates, it nay be prudent to lock up your babies, ignore persistent door knocking and avoid public places.

Chris Hayes might have the might of the ALP machine behind him but the others have got people power.

The former policewoman turned police corruption campaigner Debbie Locke has even got a new People Power party, launched last Saturday. She has a crew of supporters to help with a hectic schedule of rail stations and shopping centres.

Also hitting train stations is the Socialist Equality Party candidate Mike Head, a senior lecturer in law at the Campbelltown campus of the University of Western Sydney. He plans “door knocking, shopping centre appearances, campaigns at UWS, TAFEs and high schools”.

The former ALP member Ned Mannoun, who is running on the slogan “Tell it like it is”, said the only thing “I know for certain in the last week of this election is that sleep will be rare”. The 23-year-old said this was the beginning of a three-year campaign aimed as spending the “rest of my life in politics”.

If the going gets tough he could take some solace from Marc Aussie-Stone, who is clocking up his 17th crack at a federal seat. The man who inspired a change to the Electoral Act years ago by changing his name to get first on the ballot paper describes himself as “Australia’s leading defeated independent candidate”. He plans to spend the week encouraging other independents to keep up the good fight.

As for Hayes - he must have been so busy on the hustings that he couldn’t find the time to answer our email or phone call.

Also, I received this email from one of the candidates. It makes a number of claims about other candidates which are sourced to local papers.

There are a few gaps in your googling of the candidates… The Campbelltown-Macarthur Advertiser has a picture and small write up on all the sixteen candidates, while the Liverpool City Champion has a profile and picture for about half of the candidates…

For example, James Young has been a member of the Liberal Party for 12 years. Somehow I don’t think he has anything to do with research into the Soviet Union.

Ned Mannoun has just joined the LIBERAL Party, and gave up his US citizenship to run for Werriwa, even though he is only 23 years old…

It is pedantic, but I should point out that these additional factoids do not represent a gap in my googling of the candidates. The claims cannot be found on the web through google.

Furthermore, it is always possible I have been misinformed, and that Ned and James are not members of the Liberal Party. So, take the above quote with a pinch of salt. If James or Ned wish to deny or further clarify these claims, drop me a line.

Googling for Werriwa

Bryan · Sunday 6 March 2005 · 1:21 pm

Let’s see what we can Google on the candidates for the Werriwa by-election.

Name, Party, Job Profile
Marcus Dudley Aussie-Stone, Independent, Progressing Rural NSW Mr Aussie-Stone is possibly Australia’s most unsuccessful serial contestant. Past efforts include: Lowe NSW 1972, Parramatta NSW 1973b, Senate NSW 1974, Bass Tas 1975b, Casey Vic 1975, Cook NSW 1975, Diamond Valley Vic 1975, Henty Vic 1975, Isaacs Vic 1975, Lang NSW 1975, Paterson NSW 1975, Werriwa NSW 1975, Wills Vic 1990, Blaxland NSW 1993 1996 1996b, Bennelong NSW 1998.

In terms of his occupation, in 1998 it was listed as “Cultural Conservation”. His current occupation is “Progressing Rural NSW”, something he manages to achieve with a postal address in Strawberry Hills, just around the corner from Sydney’s Central Railway Station.

He is also a member of the Newtown Branch of Rotary, and he has a number of links to Fiji (see here and here, for example).

He allegedly changed his name from Stone to Aussie-Stone, back in the days when names were printed on the ballot paper in alphabetical order.

Samir Bargshoon, Independent, Self Employed According to the SMH, Sam Bargshoon was a cleaning contractor for the closed Orange Grove factory outlet.

He is also a former Labor Party operative involved in branch stacking, allegedly at the behest of Mark Latham (although Latham has denied this).

The SMH article includes a nice photo of Mr Bargshoon.

He contested this seat in 2004, and got 4.87 per cent of the primary vote. For this he was paid almost $7000 in election funding.

Joe Bryant, Independent, Consultant This looks like a common name, and there may well be more than one Joe Bryant when I google.

One I found was a former deputy-mayor of Blacktown, and a “patriotic activist.”

There is also a Joe Bryant on the Citizen’s Electoral Council website, who is the National Coordinator of United People Power.

There is this rant from a Joe Bryant. Suggesting that he may be a member of the Australia First Party.

And there is the Joe Bryant who convened the Eureka Freedom Commemoration And Constitutional Convention in Ballarat in December 2004.

And the AEC know of a Joe Bryant who founded the Independent Freedom and Family movement and was President of the Independent EEF party. This one was also a Deputy Mayor of Blacktown.

These may all be same person, but then again they might not. And some or all may or may not be the Joe Bryant running in the Werriwa by-election.

Update: The SMH reported that former Blacktown councillor Joe Bryant is using a photo of his daughter rather than himself in advertising because, he says, he is too ugly. Mr Bryant has eight children and 16 grandchildren.

Charles Doggett, One Nation NSW Division, Pensioner There does not appear to be anything about Charlie on the One Nation website.

He contested this seat in 2004, and got 2.36 per cent of the primary vote.

Chris Hayes, Australian Labor Party, Small Business Owner The official biography can be found on the Labor Party website. Usual stuff: 49 years old, married with three adult children, etc.

Here is a piece on his work as a consultant to the Police Federation. I found the following paragraph amusing.

“We struggled to talk to ministers,” says PFA consultant, Chris Hayes. “People didn’t want to have anything to do with us. We were just seen as somebody else turning up, and probably just another trade union.”

Mike Head, Socialist Equality Party, University Lecturer Although not listed on the ballot paper, Mike Head is contesting this seat for the Socialist Equality Party.

There is an official biography here:

Mike Head, 52, stood for the SEP in Werriwa in the October 2004 federal election. He joined the Socialist Labour League (SLL), the predecessor to the SEP, in 1975. He was born in Melbourne and attended school there before studying law at Monash University and New York’s Columbia University. In 1981 he stood as the SLL’s candidate in the federal seat of Wills against former ACTU president Bob Hawke, and in 1995 stood in Campbelltown in the NSW state elections. Between 1985 and 1998 Head was editor of Workers News. Married with three children, he currently lectures in law at the University of Western Sydney and is a regular contributor to the World Socialist Web Site on Australian and international politics.

He contested this seat in 2004, and got 0.64 per cent of the primary vote.

Mal Lees, Independent, Announcer Mal Lees was one half of the Club Veg team. According to the SMH The Club Veg team of Vic Davies and Mal Lees emerged on Triple J, grew big on Triple M, then imploded. Lees is currently heard on C91.3FM.

The SMH also has this on Lees

Perhaps the biggest statement came from local shock jock Mal Lees saying that the by-election in the safe-Labor seat is a bit of joke.

The unlikely winner is running as an independent for Werriwa as a prank.

The radio commentator, heard on Campbelltown station C91.3, said his platforms will be free beer, abolishing tollways and holding a loud-shirt day once a month in parliament.

“I will be making a myriad of promises I don’t intend to keep over the coming weeks,” Mr Lees said.

“I will not be sending my proposals to treasury for costing.”

Mal works here. There is also a picture of Mal with Mark Latham here.

Deborah Locke, People Power Party, Writer/Author Ms Locke is a police whistleblower and founder of the People Power Party.

Official biographies are here and here.

People Power has selected Deborah Locke to contest the Werriwa by-election on 19 March.

The by-election follows Mark Latham’s resignation from federal parliament.

Deborah is a former Detective in the NSW Police who blew the whistle on police corruption in the 1990s, and with independent MP John Hatton, initiated the Wood Royal Commission. Her first book Watching the Detectives (ABC Books) described this story. She is currently writing a book concerning the investigation into the death of an Australian Protective Services Officer in 2002.

Deborah is frequently called upon as a speaker and commentator on issues of police culture and ethics. She has been a longstanding member of Whistleblowers Australia.

Deborah and her husband, Greg have three children - Vanessa (12), Hayes (8) and Bronte (7). Hayes has autism, ADHD, and an intellectual disability. Through her experiences with Hayes, Deborah has added disability and carer issues to her campaigning agenda. She is a board member of the Learning Difficulties Coalition of NSW and a founding member (currently, secretary) of the Inner West Autism and Aspergers Support Group.

There is also a letter from Debbie.

Ms Locke is the only contestant to spam me so far, (she even used my work email address). It was pretty pointless as I do not live in the seat of Werriwa.

Mary Patricia McGookin, Progressive Labour Party, Marketing The official biography is here:

Patricia McGookin, emigrated from Northern Ireland 30 years ago and recently as a mature aged, part time student gained an Honours Degree in Political Science at Western Sydney

There is also a media release here.

Pat’s email address suggests she might work here.

Ned Mannoun, -, Managing Director According to the SMH, Mr Mannoun is a 23 year-old, ex-ALP member and a former chairman of Liverpool Youth Council.

He said he was not disappointed that he was last on the ballot paper.

“I’m lucky last, so I’ll stand out from the crowd,” he said.

Mr Mannoun, who will campaign mainly on upgrading the M5 motorway, said he was a “controversial” candidate because he “wasn’t here to hug and kiss babies”.

“What I am here to do is make sure those babies have a strong future,” he said.

Ned’s email address suggests he might work here.

Ben Raue, The Greens, Student According to the official biography, “Ben is a 19-year-old student of Economics and Social Science at the University of Sydney. A resident of Raby, he has lived his whole life in Werriwa.”

He is also a regular at Inside Politics where he uses the handle Sven and signs his posts,

Member for Werriwa
Social Democratic Green Party

He is a regular at the Sydney University Greens on Campus. (Note: there is something slightly odd about that last link).

Ben is the author of this paper on Constitutional Change.

He contested this seat in 2004, and got 3.13 per cent of the primary vote.

Mick Sykes, Family First, Financial Adviser According to Nine, “Mr Sykes, 43, is a financial planner who has been married for 18 years and has two children.”

As far as I can see, there is nothing on the Family First website about Mick.

Greg Tan, Christian Democratic Party (Fred Nile Group), Graphic Designer According to the official biography,

Greg is a third generation Australian and he has a passionate love for this country. He’s been married to Amanda for 14 years and has 6 children. Greg has lived in the Western Suburbs for most of his life. Greg is trained as a graphic designer and runs a small business, Leaflet Design, designing corporate logos and brochures. He also teaches a number of religious education classes in local schools - a role he has enjoyed for over 20 years.

Both the above links have photos of Greg. He looks remarkably young to have been married for 14 years.

Greg contested the seat of Greenway in 2004, and got 2.82 per cent of the vote.

He contested Werriwa in 2001 where he got 2.46 per cent of the vote.

Robert Vogler, Independent, Small Business Owner Mr Vogler has designed a new green and gold Australian flags and has also written an outline for a new Australian Republic model. His aim is to publicise this new Republic model by running as an Independent.

Robert contested the seat of Wentworth in 2004, and got 0.46 per cent of the vote.

Janey Woodger, Australians Against Further Immigration, Secretary Google did not reveal that much, other than Edwin and Janey Woodger have been contesting seats for the Australians Against Further Immigration Party for almost ten years.

Janey contested Werriwa in 2001 where she got 1.76 per cent of the vote.

She has also stood for the NSW Parliament on a number of occasions, including the Campbelltown by-election in 2001, where she got 8.3 per cent of the vote.

James Young, Independent, Sales Advisor Who knows? Could this be him? Probably not.

Update: Finally a little something on James Young from the SMH

Liberal Party member James Young is running as an independent after party headquarters decided to save money and not run. He is directing preferences to former Blacktown councillor Joe Bryant.

Note: From the addresses given to the Australian Electoral Commission, it appears that only 6 of the 16 candidates — Bargshoon, Doggert, Hayes, Mannoun, Raue, and Sykes — live in the electorate of Werriwa (see map).

If I have missed anything, let me know and I will include it above

The candidates

Bryan · Friday 25 February 2005 · 8:24 pm

The Australian Electoral Commission has announced the 16 candidates for the Werriwa by-election:

Candidate Name Party Ballot Name
WOODGER, Janey Australians Against Further Immigration
RAUE, Ben The Greens
YOUNG, James Independent
LEES, Mal Independent
HAYES, Chris Australian Labor Party
VOGLER, Robert Independent
TAN, Greg Christian Democratic Party (Fred Nile Group)
BRYANT, Joe Independent
DOGGETT, Charles One Nation NSW Division
HEAD, Mike
SYKES, Mick Family First
BARGSHOON, Sam Independent
MCGOOKIN, Mary Patricia Progressive Labour Party
LOCKE, Deborah
AUSSIE-STONE, Marc Independent
MANNOUN, Ned

Help wanted: if you know the web-links to any of these people’s home pages or the like, please let me know.

Note: My earlier speculation on possible candidates is here.

Werriwa: the Cunningham factor

Bryan · Monday 21 February 2005 · 5:05 am

According to Mike Seccombe in today’s SMH, Labor fears another Cunningham.

Ironically, Labor would have preferred the Liberals to run, if only, as one party strategist put it, to give the numerous minor party and independent candidates “someone else to hate”.

With Labor the only major party standing, all other candidates were then encouraged to “gang up” against them through complex preference swaps in the hope of winning.

“This looks dangerously similar to Cunningham,” said one of Labor’s strategists yesterday, referring to a by-election in similar circumstances in 2002.

Like the Greens, I think this is little more than scare-mongering designed to frighten longstanding Labor voters into voting for Labor.

Speaking of tactics, I just loved the text-book quote at the end of the article. Here we have Labor playing the cautious-but-confident role perfectly with an appropriate touch of the underdog. It neither takes the electorate for granted nor concedes the contest.

Labor’s NSW general secretary, Mark Arbib, confirmed Werriwa was “going to be an extremely difficult and tricky by-election”.

“But the party has a strong candidate in the field, and it is still possible to win the seat,” Mr Arbib said.

Frankly, I would be surprised if Labor did not win the by-election. In my view the socio-demographics of Werriwa differ from Cunningham, making a Green outcome unlikely.

Werriwa: no Liberal candidate

Bryan · Sunday 20 February 2005 · 11:35 am

According to yesterday’s SMH, the Liberals will not be contesting the seat of Werriwa.

The state executive of the NSW Liberal Party decided at a meeting not to contest the by-election prompted by Mr Latham’s resignation due to illness in January.

NSW Liberal state president Chris McDiven said the decision was made after careful consideration and consultation.

“The party has consulted widely with the local community, party members and the federal and state parliamentary wings,” Mr McDiven said in a statement.

As the Greens have gone for a greenhorn, Labor only needs to worry about a high profile independent. This race is starting to look over before it begins.